Complete Spanish

Track 29

1. Two verbs for "to be" Concept

Spanish has two verbs where English has one. Ser is about characteristics, and it is where es and son come from. Estar is about states, and the English word state is related to it.

ser
characteristics of something
estar
states something is in

So Spanish permits you, and obliges you, to make a decision every time: is this a state, or is it a characteristic?

Testing it out: being tired is a state. Where you are is a state. Being a good or bad person is a characteristic.

The teacher frames this not as an obstacle but as part of the experience of learning a language: it makes you realise that your own language both permits and obliges you to perceive and express the world in a certain way.

2. Do not simplify it to temporary and permanent Heads-up

Most learners, and many teachers, reduce this to temporary against permanent. Snub out that temptation now. It works most of the time, but not all of the time.

The example that breaks it: I am a student is not very permanent, but your profession is, according to Spanish, characteristic of you. Even if you do it for five minutes.

If you simplify it, you will feel frustrated many times, as though there is something you do not understand, because Spanish disagrees with you. If you hold the concepts of state and characteristic instead, the few disagreements become an interesting point of perspective.

Being aggressive is the same case: someone can be aggressive and then change, so it is not permanent, but it is still a characteristic.

Some adjectives can be used with both, giving different meanings, but the great bulk go with one or the other.

3. The forms of estar Grammar

Two irregularities, and that is all. I am is estoy, ending -oy like voy.

estoy
I am
está
he/she/it is, you (formal) are
están
they are, you (plural) are
estás
you (informal) are
estamos
we are

For a verb meaning to be, this is remarkably tame. English gets am, is, are, was out of to be.

4. The one verb with the accent on the ending Rule

The second irregularity is worth its own note. Estar is the only verb in the entire Spanish language that does not put the accent on the penultimate syllable in the present tense.

estoy, not "éstoy"

The accent goes on the ending. This has not happened until now, and it will not happen again. The "we" form is the exception to the exception: estamos has the accent where you would expect, because you are adding two syllables.

5. Some form of the verb is often the noun Vocabulary

Here the noun is the complete "to" form itself. Un ser is a being.

un ser
a being
un ser humano
a human being
cansado
tired
muerto
dead

There is no rule that gets you to humano, but humanity gives humanidad, and from there you can guess humano.

6. States in practice Grammar

Tired is a state, so it takes estar. That holds even when you say always, because the question is never how long it lasts.

Estoy cansado · Estamos cansados · Estamos cansadas · Estoy cansado siempre · Estoy siempre cansado · Siempre estoy cansado

Siempre is very flexible in that sentence. Moving it changes the emphasis but it is legal anywhere.

Death is a state too, so I am dead is estoy muerto. It also works as a way of saying I am very tired.